Showing posts with label Greensboro police accountability. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Greensboro police accountability. Show all posts

Buchanan found not guilty of assaulting, resisting officer

Ashley Buchanan, a Bennett College graduate who had been charged with two misdemeanor offenses stemming from an April incident, was found not guilty during her hearing in Guilford County District Court today.

Judge Wendy Enochs announced the verdict at approximately 5:30 p.m, following testimonies from witnesses, as well as closing statements from the state, and Buchanan's representative, Jason Keith.

Buchanan was one of four women arrested during an April graduation party at the Sebastian Village apartment complex. She was charged with assaulting a government official and resisting an officer while police attempted to disperse the party due to excessive noise and occupancy.

Buchanan and six other attendees of the party testified during the hearing. They all claimed that police used profanity and excessive force in the incident.

Fresh allegations of Greensboro police misconduct

The Beloved Community Center posted this pretty disturbing video interview with Marie Robinson earlier this week alleging unprovoked abuse and wrongful arrest by Greensboro police officers in April. Robinson's story is just the latest allegation of police misconduct that the Beloved Community Center has highlighted, most of which are made by residents of color.


 Watch this video where Robinson describes being slammed against her car in her fiancĂ©'s driveway after police accused her of being a prostitute. Robinson, who is diabetic, says her fiancĂ© was helping her with her blood sugar when police appeared. Ultimately, she says, police arrested both of them.

YES! Weekly has not yet verified any of the claims in the video. Chief Ken Miller was not immediately available for comment.

Related:
Police treatment of Bennet, A&T students leaves sour taste
Speakers urge citizens to mobilize against police abuses

Charles Cherry has more choice words for mayor, city manager

Former Greensboro police captain Charles Cherry has developed a reputation amongst Greensboro City Council members for his choice words at council meetings to such an extent that they considered limiting speech and the public comment period at their meetings last summer. Mayor Robbie Perkins, a frequent target of Cherry's criticism, explained his thoughts about speakers like Cherry again this April:

"Frankly, the concern I have is that they are taking away from folks that really need our help," he said. "Some may want to come in and don’t because they don’t want to be in middle of acrimonious discussion." 

Today, the saga continues. In a dual complaint/public-information request to the city, Cherry wrote to "Deadbeat, Non Taxpaying, Looking for Preferential Treatment Mayor Perkins and the other eight members of city council." Cherry criticized Perkins' bankruptcy and non-payment of taxes, going on to call City Manager Denise Turner Roth "a corrupt stupid liar."

Cherry has repeatedly argued that the city refuses to investigate his complaints about police misconduct. Roth contends that the city has answered his requests and staff recommends that council not address Cherry directly because of his pending lawsuit against the city. 

There is another gem in Cherry's complaint, too:

"Robbie, never forget, I am strengthened by the Mighty God in Heaven. Greensboro, observe the power of a God-fearing man, as I mentally dominate, control and force this corrupt deadbeat mayor to do his job." 

He ends the letter by requesting the name, dates, result and amount of money spent on each pending or current lawsuit involving the Greensboro Police Department since January 1, 2010, including outside lawyer fees or estimated cost of staff time based on salary. YES! Weekly asked the city to release the results of Cherry's public-information request to us as soon as it is available to him. 

Cherry's case is one of many cited by a report, Our Democratic Mission, released by the Beloved Community Center earlier this year highlighting issues that point to a "subculture of corruption and double standards" in the police department. The center is holding a community meeting on June 13 to discuss issues related to the department.

Read: Bennett and A&T student complaints about Greensboro police

Today's dirt article about two incidents between Bennett College students and Greensboro police references the complaints that students filed with the city after the incidents in Sebastian Village apartments. In the first incident, students describe how they were treated when police knocked on their door looking for an armed robbery suspect and in the second, Bennett students celebrating graduation give their version of a night that led to four arrests after noise complaint calls.

Read the complaint and other relevant documents from the first incident here.

For some reason I am having technical difficulties uploading the complaints from the second incident but I will update this post as soon as possible. I apologize for the inconvenience.

Beloved Community Center Meeting calls for action

Fired police officers Charles Cherry, Joseph Pryor and A.J. Blake

Amidst prayers and passionate speeches, a plan of action came to the forefront of the Beloved Community Center meeting on police misconduct.

Beloved Community Center board chair Pat Priest and community organizer Joseph Frierson asked for participation the entire night of April 4, and they got more than they might have expected when Mayor Pro Tem Yvonne Johnson said she believed the Greensboro City Council could muster five votes to create a police citizens review board.

After an audience member asked how to go about getting a review board, Johnson replied, “All you have to do is bring a request to city council, and we’ll vote on it…. I think you probably have five people who will vote for it.”
 

The night centered on Our Democratic Mission, a Beloved report released in January detailing 14 separate cases of alleged police misconduct. The document was referenced throughout the night as a way to mobilize the community to address concerns raised in the report. The first speaker of the night, the Rt. Rev. Alfred C. Marble, assisting bishop of the Episcopal Diocese of North Carolina and board member at Beloved, commented on the necessity of community involvement.

“Greensboro is predominately a black and white community, but it is an international community,” Marble said. “We need everyone to get involved.”

After speeches from Marble, and the Rev. Nelson Johnson, executive director of the Beloved Community Center, and case reviews from Bennett College student Imani Wilburg-Folds and Brian C. Sims of NC A&T University, Beloved conveners opened the floor to questions. The first inquiry stirred the crowd as A&T student Alicia Funderburke asked how she could get involved. A series of answers led to the greater idea, brought forward by lawyer and civil rights activist Lewis Pitts.

“The most patriotic thing we can do is stand up and fight,” Pitts said.

Later, Pitts hit at the heart of the issue: “Who do we allow to wear guns and lock up citizens?” he asked. “We must be able to hold them accountable.”

Guilford College associate professor Sherry Giles agreed. She stated more than once a need for a citizens review board to hold the police accountable. Working with her students, she said they most often came to a recurring question: “How do we give power back to the citizens?”
The question rang true throughout the meeting. Before a video showing some of the more harrowing cases in Greensboro’s troubled past with police brutality, Vice-Chairperson Dale Tonkins introduced three former Greensboro police officers, Joseph Pryor, Charles Cherry and A.J. Blake, who are characterized in the report as having been wrongfully terminated.

While those cases dominated the night, the meeting’s framework built around a cry for citizen involvement. Marble called for Greensboro leadership to sit with Beloved staff and board members to discuss the past and the future.

“List every error in our publication so we can talk about this,” Marble said. “The council wants to blame it all on Nov. 3, 1979 and though no justice was found for that day, the problem continues.”

Marble referred to a case detailed in Our Democratic Mission involving Greensboro police. According to the Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s final report on the incident, “the majority of commissioners find the single most important element that contributed to the violent outcome of the confrontation was the absence of the police.”

Rev. Johnson echoed Marble’s sentiments during the question-and-answer period. He called for a meeting about Our Democratic Mission before saying, “I know there is corruption because I have seen it. The internal police mechanism is flawed.”
 

He called for organization at every level, “every campus, every neighborhood and every church,” to bring forth the change Beloved eagerly desires.

Occupy Greensboro to discuss police surveillance


Occupy Greensboro is calling for a "general assembly" meeting to discuss "police surveillance and Greensboro official actions against peaceful protest." The meeting will start will public interest lawyer Lewis Pitts' statement at the last Greensboro City Council meeting "about suspected police forgeries of city council emails," according to an announcement sent out over the Peace & Justice Network listserve. The general assembly meeting will be held March 24 from 4 - 6 p.m. at Glenwood Coffee & Books (1310 Glenwood Street). 

It's been a month and a half since my cover story on police surveillance of activists in Greensboro, which led to several follow up articles in subsequent weeks. We don't normally link to other news sources (and we did practically all of the reporting on this issue) but Joe Gamm at the News & Record had an interesting blog post about surveillance soon after.  If anyone is interested in Pitts' comments to council, watch the Feb. 19 video here (during the speakers from the floor portion towards the beginning). 


PHOTOS: Read document referenced in cover story

Here is the email from Officer Eddy Summers and the response (at the top) from William Hill regarding James Paschal Jr.'s death referenced in the "Twin Tragedies" cover story this week. There is some information in the email that isn't relevant to the case (I don't know who Mr. Thompson is), but overall it was the most relevant email from a public information request I filed for the story. The two images are of the same email, but it ran onto the second page. A paragraph is repeated because of how I copied the document (to show they are the same email) and isn't repeated in the email itself.

Note that the email was sent a few days after then-Cpl. Chris Schultheis shot Paschal. It is interesting to note that Summers says Paschal jumped on two officers on March 19. Paschal was on parole, and I am surprised that wouldn't qualify as a violation of his parole.



Vaughan issues memorandum on privacy of personnel records

Residents and council members alike have complained that the city hides behind "personnel issues" as a way to circumvent transparency on employee records, but City Councilwoman Nancy Vaughan issued a memorandum yesterday calling for the city's protocols on personnel requests to be more open in accordance with state law. Citing from Public Records Law for North Carolina Local Governments, Second Edition, Vaughan says the city needs to release more information than what the current interim city attorney is allowing.

"I think it’s time for us to revise our 'City’s Protocol for Public Records Request' to accurately reflect state law," Vaughan wrote.

The issue came up at last week's council meeting when Ben Holder raised concerns that Captain Hinson owns halfway homes in the precinct under his command, saying it was a conflict of interest. Vaughan was one of the council members who pushed the interim City Manager Denise Roth and interim City Attorney Jamiah Waterman to respond to Holder's concerns rather than refusing to comment because it is a personnel issue.

In the memorandum, Vaughan listed a number of things that are a matter of public record and specifically referred to Hinson's case, calling for his Outside Employment Request Form(s) to be released.

Read the full memorandum here.

Police detention of Occupy Greensboro participant continues to unfold


by Eric Ginsburg. Photo by Alexandria Stewart

As YES! Weekly reported in this week's issue, Occupy Greensboro participant Zack Sadeq said Greensboro police Officer Muldowney stopped him last week while he was walking back to the camp in the YWCA parking lot after following him as he walked to Jimmy Johns. Sadeq said Muldowney questioned him about his participation with Occupy Greensboro as well as his Che Guevara t-shirt.

After being detained and then being told he was free to leave, Sadeq said he asked the officer why he had been stopped and that Muldowney replied that Sadeq fit the description of a suspect in connection to a string of auto larcenies in the downtown area.

Sadeq, shown in the photo above, looks distinct, raising questions about what exactly the police profile for the larcenies entailed.

The record of reported incidents on the police website for the days preceding Sadeq's detention confirm that there were indeed a number of auto larcenies in the downtown area, but no suspect description was provided. Susan Danielson, a public information officer with the police department, confirmed the larcenies, but said there is no profile of the suspect or suspects and that the department asks anyone with information to contact them.

Officer Muldowney could not be reached to comment.

Greensboro police administrative discourse

City Manager Rashad Young to police Capt. Charles Cherry, July 29 >

Assistant City Manager Michael Speedling to Capt. Cherry, July 29 >

Capt. Cherry to City Manager Young, July 30 >

Capt. Cherry to City Manager Young, Aug. 2 >

Newly-appointed police chief Ken Miller to press, Aug. 2: "I will say moving forward that I think City Manager Young and Assistant City Manager Speedling have already begun working since, I guess, about February with Chief Bellamy to address many of these issues. I really feel like in many respects I’m coming into an organization that’s starting to right itself in that regard, or at least from the perception standpoint, some of the internal turmoil. I also believe that the organization is, as I said earlier, fundamentally sound."


Will the Greensboro City Council demand answers on the police's treatment of Eva Foster?

Eva Foster, 85, told the Greensboro City Council on May 18 that Chief Tim Bellamy had reneged on a promise to compensate her for medical costs incurred in the aftermath of a traumatic experience in which she was caught up in a police raid on Oriental Market on Coliseum Boulevard last September.

“A group of vice-squad members entered the place with guns drawn and told everyone to get on the floor immediately,” Foster said. “‘Put your hands behind your back.’ I attempted to do so, but failed to act fast enough. Once I was stretched out on the floor, a white police officer roughly handled me as he placed me in handcuffs. During this episode, I screamed for someone to help me. A black officer came over and helped me get off the floor. I screamed so loud that they finally let me put my hands in front of my body. I was released after they discovered I was not guilty of any crime.”

Lt. Hope Newkirk describes the operation this way to Assistant City Manager Michael Speedling in a May 27 memo: “On 9/21/2009 a search warrant was executed at Phongsavanh Oriental Food Mart located at 1810 Coliseum Blvd. The vice-narcotics division had previously received a complaint alleging that an illegal sports betting operation was being operated at this location. The officers involved in the execution of the search warrant were members of the vice-narcotics division, gang unit and southern patrol division. In addition, two Guilford County medics were present to address any possible injuries occurring to the officers, citizens or suspects at the time of the search warrant being executed.

“Upon the officers entering the business all subjects inside the business were given verbal commands to show their hands and lay on the floor for officer safety reasons,” the Newkirk memo continues. “During this time a male subject tried to conceal cocaine and a handgun belonging to one of the subjects which was also located. Inside the room where the officers initially made their entrance were numerous subjects involved in illegal sports betting. This is also the room where Mrs. Foster was when the officers entered the business. The focus of this investigation was only directed at the parties involved in running the illegal sports betting operation and not directed at individuals placing bets.”

Then-Mayor Yvonne Johnson intervened on behalf of Foster, and asked Chief Bellamy to visit her at home to discuss her concern.

“A few days later, the mayor came by,” Foster told the council earlier this month. “[Chief Bellamy] said, ‘Don’t worry about a thing.’ He gave me a card to call him. And he would get things straightened out about my bills. I was unable to sleep because of insomnia. I called Chief Bellamy to let him know that the bills were piled up. He said, ‘I don’t remember being at your house.’ I said, ‘Well, you don’t remember giving me your card with your private number on it?’ No. He said, ‘Well, maybe you need to talk to the Salvation Army.’”

Newkirk states that although Foster told Bellamy that her arm was broken, “there were no visible signs of injury.”

The Newkirk memo was sent out to council members yesterday in the City Manager’s weekly Items For Your Information packet. The lieutenant reports that Foster indicated to the chief that she was concerned about her medical bills, and her “request was referred to the Insurance Advisory Board to determine if the bills should be paid by the city. In January Mrs. Foster spoke with professional standards. During the conversation, she advised Mrs. Santor that her only concern was her injury (crushed bone in her wrist from being handcuffed) and incurred medical costs. Mrs. Santor provided her contact information for the Insurance Advisory Board and contact information for professional standards in case she had additional questions or concerns.

So ends the Newkirk memo.

A couple questions arise: Did Chief Bellamy or anyone in the police department substantiate the injuries reported by Foster? Did anyone request and obtain copies of medical bills from Foster? Will Foster be compensated by the city for her reported injuries?

Will members of city council be asking these questions?

New Kirk

Newkirk memo2