Showing posts with label solid waste. Show all posts
Showing posts with label solid waste. Show all posts

Gate City sues to block Vaughan from voting on solid waste contract

Gate City Waste Services files a complaint (link) seeking an injunction to affect Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny's participation in a vote on the selection of the solid waste company to operate the White Street Landfill.

Complaint:

Plaintiff respectfully requests that the court declare that: (i) Ms. Vaughan has a “financial interest” within the meaning of NC Gen. Stat. § 160A-75 in the award of the contract and therefore has a conflict of interest and is required to recuse herself from voting and participating in the proceedings related to the award of the contract; and (ii) Mr. Matheny has no “financial interest” within the meaning of NC Gen. Stat. § 160A-75 or any other conflict of interest in the award of the contract and is therefore not excused from voting and participating in the proceedings relating to the award of the contract.


Vaughan told me today that she expects her pro-landfill colleagues on council to take a vote to recuse her from the landfill decision against her will, adding that she believes tonight's vote is tied to the lawsuit filed today because if the vote is successful the city would be enjoined from representing her as a defendant.

Vaughan said that interim City Attorney Tom Pollard has been researching the matter this afternoon and determined that the city council does have the authority to take a vote to recuse the mayor pro tem against her will.

"He thinks it can be done," Vaughan said. "From what I understand, he thinks it's not something that should be done lightly. It's certainly not something done regularly. It should be done only in the most extreme circumstances."

Chris Brook, a staff attorney at the Southern Coalition for Social Justice, has been monitoring events today. Brook said Pollard has determined that all members should vote on Vaughan's possible recusal.

A key fulcrum of the vote tonight is likely to be Matheny's role.

"Even though Matheny is conflicted out of voting on Gate City, he could vote to recuse Nancy, which would help Gate City," Brook said. "My understanding from talking to people is that Matheny is saying, 'I don't want to vote'.... If he is deemed okay to vote and he doesn't vote then he would be counted as a yes vote. That strikes me as too cute by half. By default he's voting yes, and then by default he's voting for the company that he claimed to have a conflict with."

UPDATE: "I don’t know if I’ve ever seen it done before, but I do think it’s possible for council to take that action," says Tom Pollard, who served as city attorney for the city of Wilmington from 1983 to 2009.

"It would just be the statutes that apply to a conflict of interest and the council making the decision that the statutes apply to a member of council," Pollard said, explaining the legal basis for his decision.

UPDATE2: Tonight's city council meeting begins at 5:30 p.m.


Solid waste vendor proposes to take over gas development at landfill

Gate City Waste Services proposes (link) "four additional solid waste management related services" after being preselected as a solid waste vendor to operate the White Street Landfill by the Greensboro City Council last month.


Pollard: Vaughan should vote on landfill decision

Greensboro interim City Attorney Tom Pollard reaffirms his opinion that Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan should vote in an upcoming decision to contract a private vendor to reopen the White Street Landfill in a letter (link) to a lawyer representing Gate City Waste Services.

Pollard explains his decision to the city council in an e-mail after the jump:

Dear Mayor and City Council Members:

Several questions were raised about my memorandum of August 22, 2011 to Ms. Vaughan about her participation in the vote to award a contract to Gate City following the public hearing scheduled for September 20. I have reviewed all of the additional information that I have received from council members as well as a letter that I received from Mr. Steven Levitas, the attorney for Gate City. After considering all of this information, I do not see any reason to change my opinion. Attached is a letter to Mr. Levitas that explains my reasoning. The letter only addresses the points made in Mr. Levitas’ letter. Additional concerns have been raised. First, the proposed push and pack operation may affect the methane gas production at the landfill, and Ms. Vaughan’s husband has represented Cone Mills in contract negotiations relating to the use of the methane gas. Second, Waste Industries’ proposal is technically alive and could be considered if the contract with Gate City is not approved.

As to the first concern, I have been advised that the RFP did not address the methane gas production, and the city will continue to maintain the methane gas operation. In addition, the landfill produces more methane gas than Cone Mills uses. There is no clear link between an award of a contract for the push and pack operation and a financial impact on Cone Mills or Ms. Vaughan’s husband.

While I believe that my letter to Mr. Levitas addresses the second concern, the possible future consideration of Waste Industries proposal is not enough to bar Ms. Vaughan from voting on September 20.

If you have any questions, please let me know.

Thomas C. Pollard
Interim City Attorney
City of Greensboro

Brother, can you spare $12.50?

Greensboro property owners: Are you willing to pony up $12.50 per year to keep the White Street Landfill closed?

That's how much the city manager's office estimates that a homeowner could save on their taxes assuming their house is assessed at $100,000 of valuation, based on the "push and pack" option to reopen the landfill that was approved by council last week.

The tax rate reduction that could be realized is 1.25 cents.

Staff ran the numbers in response to a question posed by Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan at yesterday's briefing session.

That said, no promise has been made that the savings realized from reopening the landfill will be realized. To the contrary, at-large Councilman Danny Thompson has been talking up the idea of plowing the savings from reopening the landfill into a solid waste enterprise fund to purchase an equity stake in a future regional landfill.

Ed Cone has also explored that idea.


Discussions about regional solid waste option begin

Robbie Perkins (back to camera) discusses his interest in pursuing a regional solid waste solution with fellow city council members (l-r) Mary Rakestraw, Trudy Wade and Dianne Bellamy-Small.

Prompted by a recent development allowing Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan to have a vote in the city of Greensboro’s contentious solid waste process, Councilman Robbie Perkins sought in vain to get the city to open up talks with Randolph County to explore the possibility of sending the city’s solid waste to a planned regional landfill there.

Perkins said he asked Mayor Bill Knight to put the proposal on the agenda for a briefing meeting this afternoon at city hall, and the mayor refused, saying the timing was “premature.” So Perkins raised his proposal during the half-hour segment at the beginning of the meeting set aside for members of the public to address council.

But the topic came up at the end of the briefing anyway. After brief and unremarkable presentations from Downtown Greensboro Inc. and an executive search firm contracted to help the city council find a new city attorney, members held a candid and sometimes contentious discussion about solid waste options and Vaughan’s role in the process. Knight declared the briefing over, stated that people could speak whenever they felt like it and left before the discussion was through.

“Since the city attorney ruled that Ms. Vaughan is back in the mix in terms of voting on the contract, it seems like the dynamic in this discussion has changed,” Perkins said. “And so I thought it would be appropriate for the council to at least take a look at the Randolph County option, not in terms of us buying a piece of their landfill but just having the manager discuss with them what type of contract could be worked out with them and what type of tipping fee they would charge.”

County officials estimate that the landfill will be open in 18 months to two years.

Councilwoman Trudy Wade, who made the motion at last weeks’ meeting to reopen Phase III of the White Street Landfill and initiate contract negotiations with Gate City Waste Services, dismissed Perkins’ proposal.

“I just think we might be jumping the gun on going long range at this point when we’ve just chosen someone to do something at the landfill,” Wade said. “I just think we should see if this company that we’re supposedly going to contract with has a long-term plan for us or has anything they might add to the discussion before we as a city jump out…. So I think it’s only fair if you’re going to negotiate a contract [to] see if the vendor you’ve chosen had any thoughts along those lines. And I think we owe it to them.”

Both Perkins and Councilman Danny Thompson have expressed interest in a long-term, regional solution to the city’s solid waste challenges, but Perkins leans toward having the city be a customer while Thompson has recently suggested temporarily reopening the White Street Landfill and plowing the funds into a solid waste enterprise fund that could be used to buy an equity stake in a future regional landfill.

“It would seem to me that if we were going to negotiate with Randolph on the front end and be their money source for that new expansion of the landfill and we had the opportunity to direct as much waste as we produce to their facility, then you could negotiate very, very favorable terms,” Perkins said. “Just like an anchor tenant does with a shopping center, they always get the best deal. And we would be Randolph County’s anchor tenant for their landfill. And we could get one heck of a deal.”

Thompson parried, “I’m not certain that the potential of an equity partnership is not out of the realm.”

City staff and its consultant, HDR Engineering, have estimated that the city could save about $1 million on hauling were the city to divert waste from its current destination in Montgomery County to Randolph County.

“Have you talked to anybody in Randolph about that?” Perkins asked.

“I’ve talked to entities,” Thompson responded.

Perkins: “Who have you talked to?”

Thompson: “I can’t say.”

Perkins: “You can’t say. Well, I’ve talked to the chairman of the Randolph County Commission and he said he would prefer tip fees versus the other and the reason he gave was that it would be hard enough to expand that landfill without interjecting Greensboro as an owner. And that was this morning at about 11 o’clock.”

Thompson: “I would expect him to say that.”

Perkins: “So why are you trying to pursue something that they don’t want? Because you haven’t talked to anybody.”

Thompson: “No, I have.”

Perkins: “Okay, but you won’t reveal who you talked to.”

Thompson: “Okay, there you go.”

Vaughan, Perkins and Councilwoman challenged the conservative faction that has been maneuvering the city to reopen the landfill to allow the city to bid against private vendors to operate the landfill. The two sides argued on whether staff has produced those numbers to council already.

“I remember an IFYI where we documented the current costs where we provided an assumption about different tonnage levels,” City Manager Rashad Young said, “but we’ve not done an analysis on the current RFP respondents to that question.”

Thompson indicated the numbers aren't particularly significant one way or the other.

“They’re either going to do it for free or it’s going to be $1 million or $2 million,” he said.

“You don’t know that,” Perkins said. “I don’t know that. How do you know that?”

Thompson said, “We’ve already got bids on the table for $1 million and $2 million. They can either be below that – for free – or they can be at that price or higher.”

Perkins said, “Why would the city of Greensboro not be able to bid cheaper than anybody and therefore save us more money than anybody without having to make a profit on their work out there?”

Wade and Knight expressed as an article of faith that private companies can save more money than city staff an.

“We all know private industry is more efficient and does it better, because the city is going to pay you whether you’re good or you’re not good or whatever,” Wade said. “Now, I’m going to say that when you work in private industry, if you’re not producing at a certain amount you’re not going to be there very long.”

“We are trying to stop the bleeding that’s been going on,” Knight said. He added, “Private industry can do a better job, in my opinion.”

Early in the freewheeling discussion, council members discussed the ramifications of Vaughan having a vote in the landfill issue going forward.

Wade indicated that Vaughan’s husband, Don, is involved with the landfill in regards to methane reserves. The city gives methane from the landfill to Cone Mills as an economic development incentive.

“I don’t know how she’s voting on the landfill at all,” Wade said.

Vaughan responded, “That’s a totally separate issue.”

“If you want to pull Waste Industries in just to deny me my ability [to vote],” she added, “then I think that’s pretty transparent on why you’re going to do that.”

Wade responded, “If you vote against Gate City, we’re going to have a very serious problem picking anyone but Waste Industries because that would be the only way you couldn’t vote on it and you know what the vote is right now. And we’ve all seen what you’ve put [1, 2] on YES! Weekly blog.”

Vaughan has indicated in recent interviews that the city should honor a “pact” made with residents when the council voted to close the landfill about 10 years ago, and has suggested that the council hold separate votes on whether to reopen the landfill and which company to award a contract to.

“You do not know that I would support Waste Industries,” she said.

Interim City Attorney Tom Pollard said some council members have approached him about whether Vaughan should be allowed to vote, and that he plans to review information they provide him.

“It’s going to take me awhile to get through it,” he said.

Wade requested that as long as Pollard was looking into whether Vaughan has a conflict of interest, he should also investigate whether Perkins has a conflict of interest. A commercial real estate broker at Perkins’ company represents properties for DH Griffin, a Greensboro salvage company whose executives are involved with the newly formed Gate City Waste Services.

“The only reason for this pushback is you’re just hell-bent on reopening the landfill,” Perkins charged. “That’s what you want to do no matter what. Now, if you’re really looking for a solution that’s going to benefit this community, you’ve got to look in Randolph County. You can’t not look in Randolph County.”

“I don’t think anybody said they didn’t look in Randolph County,” Wade replied. “We’ve looked at technology and lot of other things, Robbie. Unless you’re just hell-bent on not opening the landfill.”

“I am hell-bent on not opening the landfill,” Perkins agreed.

“I want to be sure we’re looking at all our options,” Wade said. “And I realize we’ve lost $55 million from 2002 to now by not using the resource we’ve had.”

POSTSCRIPT: Vaughan says after the discussion Thompson produced a memo written by acting City Attorney Tom Carruthers in July that he purportedly indicates she should not participate in any ongoing solid waste deliberations. Vaughan says that if interim City Attorney Tom Pollard rescinds his opinion allowing her to vote on the matter, she will consider seeking outside counsel.

"There’s been some discussion that I’m trying to throw the vote to Waste Industries," Vaughan adds, "but I think it’ s pretty clear that I don’t want the landfill open at all."

Vaughan can vote on landfill contract with Gate City

Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan will be allowed to vote on a contract award to Gate City Waste Services to operate Phase III of the White Street Landfill.

Vaughan had previously been recused from voting on solid waste because her husband, Don Vaughan, performs legal work for Waste Industries, one of the proposers. Last Tuesday, council voted by a narrow majority to initiate contract negotiations with another proposer, Gate City Waste Services.

Pollard wrote in a letter yesterday,

You have inquired about your voting status on the award of the contract to Gate City Waste Services LLC when this contract is considered following the public hearing on September 20, 2011. I have reviewed the action of the city council to date, the prior opinions on conflicts of interest relating to this matter, the relevant state law, city charter provisions and city policies. Under GS 160A-75, there is a strong public policy of requiring members to vote unless a member has a financial interest in an outcome whether beneficial or detrimental. In my opinion, there is no basis to excuse you from voting on the contract award to Gate City.


The Aug. 16 vote to initiate contract negotiations fell 4-3, with Mayor Bill Knight, at-large Councilman Danny Thompson, District 4 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw and District 5 Councilwoman Trudy Wade in the majority. Knight, Thompson, Rakestraw and Wade have consistently voted in favor of reopening the landfill. Vaughan and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny have been recused from voting on the landfill, Vaughan because of her conflict of interest on Waste Industries and Matheny because of a financial interest in Gate City Waste Services.

Pollard wrote to Vaughan in his opinion: "You have advised me that your connection to an unsuccessful proposer will not affect your judgment about what action on the contract is in the best interest of the city."

Vaughan voted in 2001 to close the landfill to household waste.

“When it was closed to municipal solid waste, I think we made a pact with the neighborhood,” she said, “and they should have been able to expect that would be respected.”

With Matheny recused because of his relationship with Gate City Waste Services, eight members of council will be allowed to vote at the Sept. 20 hearing. If the vote were to be tied 4 to 4, the motion would fail, and Gate City would not be selected as the contractor.

After that?

"It would be then up to the council to make a decision as to how proceed," Pollard said. "They could perhaps go to another proposer and go to the public hearing process again. There are probably other things they could consider."

If Waste Industries were to be reconsidered, Pollard confirmed that Vaughan would be conflicted out again.

"Maybe the council should have a straight up or down vote — vendors aside — on whether to reopen the landfill," Vaughan said in an interview today. "This council has never had a vote on should we reopen the landfill.

"The regional solution has not been thoroughly explored," Vaughan added. "It certainly is gaining more feasibility. And to not explore it is poor judgment. I went on record 10 years ago that a regional landfill was the solution. Now we have a regional landfill on the verge of reopening [in Randolph County], and we’re not in discussions with them. They are interested in Greensboro, which is the most important factor."

City of Greensboro to issue new solid waste RFP

The Greensboro City Council is directing staff to issue a new request for proposals to solicit private vendors to operate Phase III of the White Street Landfill.

The council came out of closed session to take the vote during a special meeting to discuss a lawsuit filed against the city by northeast Greensboro residents who oppose the reopening of the landfill. The council also voted to set aside an old request for proposals, or RFP. This will be the third one issued.

The lawsuit against the city cites state law requiring cities to hold a public hearing before permitting a new landfill, and to consider alternative sites and socio-economic data. The city had begun negotiations with two solid waste companies to operate the landfill for at least 15 years when the lawsuit was filed. The city ran into trouble because the currently permitted portion of the landfill is expected to fill to capacity in two to six years. Contracting with a company to operate the landfill for 15 years would necessarily involve obtaining permits to operate additional phases.

The new RFP also calls for accepting only 140,000 tons per year, which is the amount collected by city forces. The previous RFP would have had the landfill accepting 240,000 tons.

City Manager Rashad Young said he plans to bring the new RFP back to council for approval in two weeks.

Finalizing a contract before the next council is seated in early December, when a new majority might elect to keep the landfill closed, would be ambitious.

The RFP that was set aside today provided for a period of four months and three weeks between the date of it was issued and when council was supposed to approve the contract. By that measure, the council might approve a contract by late November -- just under the wire.


White Street Landfill decision

1. opponents2. Bill Knight2. Trudy Wade and Danny Thompson3. Mary Rakestraw4. Dianne Bellamy-Small5. Robbie Perkins
6. Jim Kee



The Greensboro City Council voted 4-3 last night to initiate contract negotiations with two companies, Gate City Waste Services and Waste Industries, to operate the White Street Landfill.

At-large Councilman Danny Thompson, who made the motion, said the reason for eliminating Advanced Disposal was that it did not outline an attractive contingency plan for an outcome in which the landfill could not be utilized and it did not express an interest in implementing waste-to-energy technology at a future date.

Voting in favor of moving forward with the process to reopen the landfill were Thompson, Mayor Bill Knight, District 4 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw and District 5 Councilwoman Trudy Wade. Those opposed were at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins, District 1 Councilwoman Dianne Bellamy-Small and District 2 Councilman Jim Kee. Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny were recused because of conflicts of interest.

And then there will be two

Opponents are expected to fill Greensboro City Council chambers this evening in anticipation of a vote to select a company to privately operate the White Street Landfill. Those who support reopening the landfill are also being encouraged to attend the meeting.

Although there is little doubt about the course set through this process, this may not be the last stop. Robbie Perkins tells me he received a phone call from Danny Thompson — both Perkins and Thompson serve at large — notifying him that the four council members who comprise a majority on this issue plan to vote to eliminate Advanced Disposal from consideration, and then ask the other two vendors, Gate City Waste Services and Waste Industries, to address the council in a briefing session next week.

Soon after, a final selection could be expected.


A legal opinion on Vaughan's conflict of interest

A legal opinion from Greensboro City Attorney Julia Danish on Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan's conflict of interest on the city's solid waste decision, compared to possible conflicts of interest by at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny:

Council Member Vaughan [spelling corrected], this e-mail is in follow up and intended to clarify the discussion that occurred at yesterday’s (4/26/11) work session regarding the White Street Landfill RFPs. During that discussion, a question was raised regarding your ability to participate in those discussions. As you were previously advised, you have an actual conflict involving a direct benefit directly related to the contract. As such, this conflict is governed by all the applicable conflict statutes, including but not limited to the state criminal statute, the state ethics statute, the applicable charter provision and city policy. Most notably, the criminal statute specifically provides that you “shall not attempt to influence any person...’’ As such, this statute prohibits participating in any discussions. Your actual direct conflict is distinguished from the other possible council member conflicts currently under review (no final determination of a conflict has been made as to those other council members). Therefore, based upon the law and the facts, you can neither participate nor vote in this matter. All of your actions to date related to the landfill have been consistent with the law.  I regret any inconvenience this may have caused you. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me.



Long form: Council decides to reopen landfill

The deliberations were relatively brief considering that the issue has been roiling the Greensboro City Council since former Councilman Mike Barber proposed it three years ago. The council indicated by a straw poll of 4-2 that it will reopen the White Street Landfill during a work session that lasted less than 90 minutes today.

“We’ve got some pretty substantial responses to this,” Mayor Bill Knight said. “Economics certainly influenced my thinking on this.” An cost-comparison analysis by consulting company HDR earlier this month found the city could save from $6.2 million to $7.9 million a year through one of the proposals to reopen the landfill.

After dispensing with some redistricting business — the council agreed to set a public hearing for next Tuesday to adopt a new district map — at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins raised some questions about whether the city could get out of a 15-year contract with a prospective vendor without incurring significant financial costs, and tried unsuccessfully to get support from fellow council members for directing staff to determine the cost to the city of operating the landfill itself.

At-large Councilman Danny Thompson quickly moved the discussion towards the result everybody seemed to know the conservative majority was headed for. He proposed eliminating Republic Services, which currently transports the city’s waste to Montgomery County, from consideration. Republic has offered to continue the service at a reduced rate.

“I don’t think we did this to try to shave 84 cents per ton off with Republic Services,” Thompson said.

Next, the council eliminated Carolina Energy Development, the sole proposer that offered to handle the city’s waste through a waste-to-energy facility, and knocked out an option offered by Advanced Disposal to operate the White Street Landfill while leaving overall management to the city. That leaves three similar proposals to privatize the White Street Landfill by Waste Industries, Advanced Disposal and a local company, Gate City Waste Services.

Today’s vote was an informal decision, but City Manager Rashad Young said he expects council ratify the decision in a formal vote at next Tuesday’s council meeting.

Knight and Thompson were joined by District 4 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw and District 5 Councilwoman Trudy Wade in supporting a move to short-list three companies proposing to reopen the White Street Landfill. District 1 Councilwoman Dianne Bellamy-Small and District 2 Councilman Jim Kee indicated that they do not support the decision.

After the votes were counted, Wade asked to staff to look into building the Cone Boulevard/Nealtown Connector to provide an alternative entrance to the landfill for the purpose of reducing the burden on residents and identifying locations for economic development in the area.

“The Nealtown Connector has been on the books for close to 30 years," Bellamy-Small protested. :The Nealtown Connector should be built, as it was deserved to give flow and connectivity to that part of northeast Greensboro regardless of whether a landfill is active or inactive. That is something that the people of that area of town should have anyway."

Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan has been recused from participating in deliberations over the solid waste issue because her husband provides legal representation to Waste Industries, one of the companies proposing to reopen the landfill. City Attorney Rita Danish was researching whether Perkins and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny have a conflict of interest because of business dealings with DH Griffin, a demolition company whose principals are partners in Gate City Waste Services, another venture seeking a contract to operate the landfill.

After the work session, Thompson deflected concerns that reopening the landfill will deter economic development in northeast Greensboro.

“It didn’t stop the Carolina Circle Mall from being built out there,” he said. “What’s preventing development is that there hasn’t been infrastructure: roads, water and sewer.”

Mary Lou Clapp, who lives about a mile from the landfill, came up and put her hand on Thompson's shoulder.

"You say all the time to the public that you spend $8 million [on the city's waste]," she said, "but you're not talking about the profit the city makes from charging for private trash."

Perkins said after the meeting: "I've known for six to eight months that the council was going to open the landfill. This has all be a charade to make it look like they want to consider all the options. This has been the goal of the majority of this council for a long time. They had to make it look like they were really concerned about it. Technology was the way they softened the blow. That didn't work out. Now, they're talking about building roads. I hope east Greensboro gets some roads out of it. They're going to get a landfill."

The Durham-based Southern Coalition for Social Justice has asked the NC Department of Environment and Natural Resources to deny a revised permit to the city of Greensboro to discard municipal solid waste in Phase III of the White Street Landfill. Both Young and Chris Brook, a staff attorney with the coalition, said they do not know when to expect a decision from the division. The coalition has threatened the city with a racial discrimination lawsuit if it goes forward with reopening the landfill. Brook wrote in a recent letter to Young that while blacks and Hispanics comprise about 40.1 percent of the city’s population, “the community most directly impacted by the White Street Landfill is overwhelmingly African-American and Hispanic.”

Young said the city has already negotiated a one-year agreement with Hilco Transport, which currently hauls the city’s trash to Montgomery County, as a contingency plan and will do the same with Republic Services now that it is no longer a contender for the city’s primary service contract.

“We would have a secondary option that involves the same process even before the lawsuit [was mentioned],” Young said.

“The action that we would potentially litigate over is if an amendment to the current MSW permit were granted by DENR or if the city or a private entity seeks to further permit to expand the landfill,” Brook said. “That’s sort of a pivot point for legal action. We do think the NC Solid Waste Act of 2007 prohibits the city of Greensboro from expanding the landfill, and if we continued along this course then the city of Greensboro and the private operators would be subject to legal action.”

Brook said he was not surprised by the council’s decision.

“I think the council has made it pretty clear that they were on this path for awhile,” he said. “I do hope that there will be some due diligence by the council as they approach a final vote and that they fully consider the negative budgetary and business aspects of reopening the landfill.”

Greensboro council moves to reopen landfill

Council members Nancy Vaughan (left), Danny Thompson, Mary Rakestraw (back to camera), Zack Matheny and Jim Kee confer before a work session today.

A majority on the Greensboro City Council has indicated support for reopening the White Street Landfill to municipal solid waste. By an informal straw poll in a work session on this afternoon, the council voted 4 to 2 to short-list three companies that are proposing to reopen the landfill: Advanced Disposal, Gate City Waste Services and Waste Industries.

The decision will have to be ratified during an official meeting with public advertisement.

Those who indicated they favor considering one of the three options to reopen the landfill include Mayor Bill Knight, at-large Councilman Danny Thompson, District 4 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw and District 5 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw. Those who indicated they are opposed to reopening the landfill were District 1 Councilwoman Dianne Bellamy-Small and District 2 Councilman Jim Kee.

Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan has recused herself from discussions about the city’s solid waste options because her husband Don Vaughan, a lawyer, represents Waste Industries.

After a brief discussion about redistricting, Vaughan left city council chambers.

City Attorney Rita Danish was researching on Tuesday afternoon whether at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins and District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny have a conflict of interest and should recuse themselves from the vote. Perkins’ commercial real estate company, NAI Piedmont Triad, is representing property for DH Griffin, part of the Gate City Waste Services group, near its headquarters on Hilltop Road. Matheny’s company, Bell Partners, has an investment partnership with DH Griffin in Atlanta.

Perkins and Matheny remained on the dais during the work session. Matheny stayed silent, while Perkins asked questions.

“[If I can speak,] that means I can taint the process, I can guide the process, I can lead the process all the way up to the finish line; I’m just not carrying the ball across the goal mark,” Matheny said. “I don’t feel it’s appropriate for me to sit here and guide this process although I can’t vote on it.”

Assistant City Attorney Jim Clark told Matheny: “The only requirement with regard to a member being excused for a conflict of interest is during a vote. Prior to that, they are free to interact, to participate in any work session in this case.”

Asked by Wade why Vaughan had leave the work session, Clark responded, “Ms. Vaughan chose to excuse herself, which she can do.”

After the meeting, Vaughan said that, in fact, she had not left the work session by choice. She said that former City Attorney Terry Wood and Deputy City Attorney Becky Jo Peterson-Buie told her “that I was not to take part in any discussion and that I should remove myself from the discussion. That was not my choice. I was following the law. I did sit down with Terry to make sure that what I was doing was in compliance. I believe that if I participated in any way, shape or form it would open the city council up to a lawsuit."

Vaughan said she was angry to learn that others participated in the work session, while she has scrupulously avoided any conflict of interest.

“If there is a question of, is there a conflict, they certainly should have not participated in this,” Vaughan said. “If they did, it would taint the process. If Robbie recuses himself from a zoning decision, he’s not able to sit up there and ask questions.”

And the winner is...

A financial comparison of six options for disposing of Greensboro's solid waste by consulting company HDR finds that the city would save the most money by with Advanced Disposal's proposal to reopen the White Street Landfill ($5.6 million per year). The three options proposed by Republic Services to continue to transport the city's trash down to Montgomery County and a proposal by Carolina Energy Development to operate a waste-to-energy facility all rank near the bottom in terms of cost savings. The proposals by the three companies that would reopen the landfill — again, no surprise — offer the greatest cost savings.


As landfill vote looms, Matheny's company involved with solid waste vendor

The employer of a Greensboro City Council member is involved in an investing partnership with a local demolition company whose CEO and president are part of venture seeking to reopen the White Street Landfill to municipal solid waste. The council will vote on an option for disposing of the city’s solid waste this spring.

Zack Matheny, who represents District 3 on the council, joined Steven D. Bell & Co. in 2008 and serves as the company’s director of investor relations. DH Griffin Sr. and David Griffin Jr., respectively the CEO and president of Greensboro-based DH Griffin Cos., are investors in MRR Southern LLC, the principal contract party in Gate City Waste Services. The latter company is among five qualified proposers seeking to handle the city’s solid waste disposal.

In 2008, Steven D. Bell & Co. announced an investment partnership with DH Griffin Cos., Jacoby Development and “a Ted-Turner-family entity” to spend about $100 million to redevelop an old Ford site adjacent to Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport. The project has come to be known as the “aerotropolis.”

“DH Griffin and Bell Partners are in a joint venture together,” said Durant Bell, a principal with the company. “Jacoby Group is the developer. DH Griffin and Bell are equity investors.”

The company has since been renamed Bell Partners.

“That was a deal we entered into with DH Griffin,” Matheny said. “It was done before me joining my company. I’m not involved in that deal. I will not profit or have to pay, depending on what happens with that deal.”

Matheny said his work has to do with recruiting people to invest in “Fund 3” and “Fund 4,” which he described as “private real estate investment opportunities,” adding that he believes the aerotropolis is financed through “Bell Fund 2.”

Becky Jo Peterson-Buie, chief deputy city attorney with the city of Greensboro, said the legal department would look into the matter to determine if the investment relationship comprises a conflict of interest and would prevent Matheny from voting on the solid waste decision.

Last June, the city council approved a new policy on conflicts of interest prohibiting “officers, employees or agents from participating in the selection, award or administration of any contract where a conflict of interest is involved or may exist, whether real or apparent.” A written policy sent out to council members by City Manager Rashad Young elaborated, “The city charter and North Carolina state law prohibits city officers, employees and agents from voting upon or otherwise participating in the selection, award or administration of contracts in which they have a direct or indirect financial interest.”

The policy further states that a conflict of interest would arise when the employee, any member of their immediate family, a partner or their employer “has a financial or other interest in the firm selected for the award.”

One council member has already been recused from voting on the landfill. Mayor Pro Tem Nancy Vaughan will not participate in the decision because her husband, Don Vaughan, is a lawyer representing proposer Waste Industries. Three members — at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins, District 1 Councilwoman Dianne Bellamy-Small and District 2 Councilman Jim Kee have pledged to vote against any proposal to reopen the landfill. Mayor Bill Knight, at-large Councilman Danny Thompson, District 4 Councilwoman Mary Rakestraw and District 5 Councilwoman Trudy Wade are fiscal conservatives who have indicated an interest in finding out the potential cost savings from reopening the landfill. Matheny is considered a swing vote.

“I certainly don’t want to recuse myself unless it’s absolutely necessary because I don’t want to avoid the decision that needs to be made,” Matheny said.

A 2008 article in The Business Journal indicates that DH Griffin brought Bell Partners into the investing partnership.

“DH Griffin, one of the largest demolition companies in the country, was hired by Jacoby to tear down the massive Ford plant, an economic mainstay in the Atlanta area since it opened in 1946,” Executive Editor Justin Catanoso wrote in the 2008 article. “When Jacoby asked David Griffin… if he wanted to invest in the project, he made a call to his friend Jon Bell in Greensboro.”

The article quotes Bell as saying, “David said since we do this kind of real estate investment for a living, he wanted to know what we thought about the prospects. This was about four months ago. I went down and looked at it; I used to live in Atlanta so I knew the potential. It didn’t take long for me to ask David to set up a meeting with Jacoby.”

During the 2009 election cycle, Knight received a $700 contribution from DH Griffin Sr. and a $300 contribution from his son, David Griffin Jr.

Keith Holliday, a former mayor, warned opponents of reopening the landfill during an impassioned speech last week that a majority of the council’s members may have already made up their minds to reopen the landfill.

“This is an absolute watershed mark,” Holliday said. “I’ve been thinking this through now for 12 months. And the reason I kept my mouth shut was I was hoping the council would wake up and understand what they’re doing. Doggone it, they just didn’t. And the reason they didn’t is because there’s a lot of things going on, ladies and gentlemen, behind the scenes that you don’t know about. There’s a lot that the media doesn’t know about. This is concerted, calculated strategy. And it’s because they think they can.”

The former mayor did not mention any current council members by name in his remarks.

Asked if he has had conversations with Knight, Thompson, Rakestraw or Wade about which option to support, Matheny responded, “Not that I’m aware.” He added that he has met with Bellamy-Small and former District 2 Councilwoman Goldie Wells.

“I’m reviewing everything,” Matheny said. “I’m being very intelligent by blending the emotion and the facts, and blending them together to make an informed decision.”

Knight, Thompson, Rakestraw and Wade could not be reached for comment.

The council is scheduled to deliberate over the solid waste question on April 26. In late May, the city expects to complete contract negotiations, and on June 7 the council is scheduled to approve an agreement.

“I feel that I’m close to a decision,” Matheny said. “I just want to have all my ducks in a row. Mr. Holliday’s antics are disappointing.”

City of Greensboro threatened with legal action over landfill

A letter to Greensboro City Manager Rashad Young from the Southern Coalition for Social Justice warns that, “in addition to constituting an unwise policy decision, the reopening of the White Street Landfill to [municipal solid waste] would subject Greensboro and prospective private landfill operators to potential legal action.”

Chris Brook, a staff attorney for the Durham-based Southern Coalition for Social Justice — which works on behalf of lower-income communities of color — states that he represents the Greensboro Citizens for Economic and Environmental Justice, “a coalition of Greensboro residents, small business owners and developers in their opposition to reopening the White Street Landfill in northeast Greensboro to MSW.”

Brook writes that the 79.3 percent of the residents living in a Census tract within a mile radius of the landfill are black while 5.5 percent are Hispanic.

“While Greensboro as a whole is 47.7 percent African American and Hispanic, the community directly impacted by the White Street Landfill is 84.8 percent African American and Hispanic,” the letter states. “Disproportionate impacts like these re-open old wounds, making it difficult for Greensboro to turn the page and move beyond its fraught history of racial conflict.”

Brook warns that a decision to reopen the landfill could jeopardize federal funding considering that it would provide a basis for filing a Title VI discrimination complaint with the US Justice Department. Likewise, Brook writes, NCGS § 130A-294(4)(c)(9) instructs the NC Department of Environment and Natural Resources to “deny an application for a permit for a solid waste management facility if the department finds that… the cumulative impact of the proposed facility, when considered in relation to other similar impacts of facilities located or proposed in the community, would have a disproportionate adverse impact on a minority or low-income community protected by Title VI of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964.”

Last week, Brook wrote to the NC Department of Environment and Natural Resources requesting that a permit application submitted by the city in February to discard municipal solid waste in Phase III of the landfill be denied, based on civil rights considerations.

Brook’s letter to the city manager raises questions about the city’s estimated cost savings from reopening the landfill and about the health risks of doing so. He also questioned the wisdom of reopening the landfill from a business and economic development standpoint.

“Four of the largest five municipalities in North Carolina have MSW landfills in their general vicinity,” Brook writes. “However, none of them dispose of their MSW as close to their population and business centers. The MSW landfill serving Charlotte is 19 miles from downtown, the MSW landfill serving Raleigh is 13 miles from downtown, and the MSW landfill serving Winston-Salem is eight miles from downtown. By way of comparison, the White Street Landfill is four miles from downtown, next to thousands of city residents, and the only portion of the city capable of supporting future residential and business expansion.

Live coverage: Greensboro City Council solid waste interviews

Meeting adjourned. Staff will have cost comparison analysis for council on April 19, and anticipates council making decision on April 26.

###

One option proposed by the company would open the landfill up to disposal from across Guilford County and possibly beyond.

###

Advanced Disposal Services Carolinas presenter says her company would save the city $30.54 per ton for handling its garbage. Assuming an annual tonnage of 243,000, she says the company could save the city $7.2 million per year. A caveat, unmentioned in the presentation, Dale Wyrick with Greensboro Field Operations has said that the amount of municipal solid waste that the city could actually guarantee a private contractor is about 130,000 per year. The staff's estimate, released today, places the potential cost savings to the city of reopening the landfill at between $3.5 million and $5.3 million.

###

Final presentation: Advanced Disposal Services Carolinas

###

I button-holed Kee during the break.

"I'm a technology person," he said. "I've always been a technology person," adding that what we've heard today proves that alternative technology is viable.

I noted that Gate City Waste Services is proposing to reopen the landfill for waste burial, while expressing interest in alternative technology without making any guarantees.

"That would be tough to consider," Kee said.

###

Presentation ends. 10-minute break. Next and last presentation: Advanced Disposal Services Carolinas.

###

Kee: "It appears that you value waste to energy.... How long would it take you to transition to a full waste to energy? Is that your intent?"

Norbert: "It is."

Kee asks when it would be feasible to transition to waste-to-energy technology.

Norbert responds that when fuel costs make it uneconomical to truck trash to a landfill out of county.

###

Norbert says he believes the best way to deliver waste to the White Street Landfill is by taking Wendover Avenue to Willow Lake Road to Huffine Mill Road to Rankin Road. "But either route gets traffic off of the more densely populated White Street."

###

Norbert says MRR Southern has received a permit to operate a C&D landfill in Wake County, and has received a permit to operate a landfill in High Point.

###

Notwithstanding that the company is proposing to reopen the landfill, Norbert says Gate City Waste Services has explored alternative technology. As energy costs rise and tipping fees increase, he says, the company and the city could explore alternative technologies. He calls it a "passion" of his.

###

Hector Norbert, Gate City Waste Services: "The big issue that could use some improvement is to deal with the yard waste and we have a plan to deal with that."

He also says the landfill could be a catalyst for the economic development of northeast Greensboro by hastening the completion of the Cone Boulevard Extension.

###

The company is offering to handle the city's waste for $24 per ton.

###

David Griffin introduces the next company, Gate City Waste Industries. This is one of three that are proposing to reopen the White Street Landfill. Gate City Waste Services is partnership between MRR Southern, DH Griffin Companies and Waste Corp.

###

Wade asks if Bertram's company has handled waste for any municipalities yet. Bertram says yes, but her answer is qualified and confusing.

This segment is over. 10 minute break before Gate City Waste Services' segment.

###

Perkins questions economic viability of project.

Perkins: "If we’ve only got 122,000 tons of waste, that’s $4.8 million a year. How are you going to gap the difference between what we’ve got in our control to pay back a $73 million loan.

Rodenbough says the sale of electricity would pay back the loan, while the city's tipping fees would pay for operations.

Perkins: "You’re going to generate $6 million of electricity per year?"

Rodenbough: "We’re going to be producing more than that."

###

Bertram says permitting would take at least a year.

Rodenbough: "This project will reduce pollution from what you have right now."

###

Kee: "There are a lot of technology disbelievers. I graduated from a technology school, so I believe in it."

###

Matheny raises questions about the financing of the project.

"What kind of guarantee, if the city of Greensboro were to choose this contract, we’d be choosing a contract based on what would hopefully happen."

###

So far, Dianne Bellamy-Small, Mary Rakestraw and Trudy Wade have not asked any questions.

###

Bertram, in answer to a question from Mayor Bill Knight: "From a technology standpoint we can get adequate insurance and bonding."

Rodenbough said his partnership would assume all the financial risk in the project.

###

Hulbert says the financing of facility could be completely covered by "private placement," or alternately the city could sign on as an investor.

###

Bertram says her company is the first waste-to-energy outfit that the US Export-Import Bank has financed. She adds, "We are on the short list for Santa Barbara County."

###

Slide indicates that the Mecca, Calif. facility that plans to use International Environmental Solutions Corp.'s advanced pyrolysis technology "will be commercially operational in April 2011."

###

Bertram notes that her company is based in California and developed the technology.

"With regards to stimulus money where there's made in the USA clauses, we can fulfill that," she says.

###

Keith Hulbert, Cadence Infrastructure, speaking.

###

A byproduct of advance pyrolysis is "carbon char." Bertram says it's not hazardous, and can be resold to fuel cement kilns.

###

Karen Bertram, with International Environmental Solutions Corp., is speaking about technology aspect of proposal.

###

Carolina Energy Development is offering to handle the city's solid waste for $40 per ton, but if an ARRA grant from the US Department of Energy came through they might be able to reduce their rate.

###

John Rodenbough, CEO of Carolina Energy Development, is giving presentation for his company. Karen Bertram, a partner whose company developed the technology, is also present. Carolina Energy Development is proposing to use advanced pyrolysis technology at the city's transfer facility on Burnt Poplar Road to handle the city's municipal solid waste.

###

Waste Industries' presentation wraps. Break time. Carolina Energy Development next on agenda. Some recent reporting here.

###

Presenter: The White Street Landfill "is an asset that you have here that can control your own destiny here in Greensboro."

###

Kee asks presenter if Waste Industries operates other landfills within municipalities. The presenter responds that, yes, Waste Industries operates a construction and demolition landfill in Holly Springs and contracts with Wake County to operate a landfill in the southern portion of the county.

###

Based on the figures presented by Waste Industries, at-large Councilman Danny Thompson says the city could save $29 per ton and $6.7 million per year.

###

Presenter: "Remember proven technology, low disposal cost… tremendous savings over the life of the contract."

###

Presenter says company hosted bus tours to Waste Industries facilities in Wake County and created a “Northeast Community Council.”

###

Company presenter says Waste Industries would maximize landfill capacity, but reduce "waste cell footprints, reducing leachate generation." Also, the company would finance a traffic study, and finance a relocation of the landfill entrance and scale house.

###

Among others, Waste Industries operates the 1,500 ton-per-day South Wake Landfill in Holly Springs through a partnership with Wake County.

###

Waste Industries is offering "a fixed disposal fee of $15/ton for all city-collected waste."

###

Waste Industries is one of three companies proposing to reopen the White Street Landfill for disposal of municipal solid waste.

###

Republic Services' presentation has wrapped. Break time. Next up: Waste Industries. Local lawyer Joe Williams, whom I believe is representing Waste Industries, has been up at the dais chatting with council members Trudy Wade, Danny Thompson and Mary Rakestraw. Williams is a member of the Simkins PAC.

###

District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny asks Isenhour: "Would you utilize White Street Landfill or consider utilizing white street landfill.... Would it not be beneficial to utilize white street?"

Isenhour responds that Uwharrie landfill can operate more cheaply than the White Street Landfill on a per-ton basis because of the former landfill's much greater capacity.

###

Mayor Bill Knight is maintaining a strict three-minute time limit for council members' questions.

###

District 2 Councilman Jim Kee, who represents the area surrounding the White Street Landfill says an environmental committee that he appointed chose Republic as its first choice. "You do have some people in the neighborhood that are pulling for you," he says.

###

Drew Isenhour, with Republic Services, says the company's Uwharrie landfill in Montgomery County has about 19 years of useful life left under the current permit. Isenhour emphasizes that Republic owns a number of landfills that could handle the city's trash.

###

Per a submittal made today, Republic proposes to load, haul and dispose of the city's solid waste at a cost to the city of $40.80 per ton for the volumes that the city produces. Field Operations Director Dale Wyrick tells me the city produces about 130,000 tons of municipal solid waste per year.

###

Republic Services, which currently handles the city's solid waste by accepting it at its landfill in Montgomery County, is making the first presentation.

###

Staff released a document just before the meeting outlining solid waste disposal cost comparisons. Staff's analysis estimates the city could save $3.5 million in the next fiscal year by reopening the landfill.

###

The Greensboro City Council is meeting as we speak to interview five proposers that are angling for a contract to handle the city's solid waste. I had planned to cover the meeting through Twitter, but my account doesn't seem to be functioning.

Feel free to comment or ask questions.

Greensboro's redistricting question: To move precincts or not

District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny is the Greensboro City Council's liaison for redistricting.

Greensboro residents got their first opportunity today to give input on the redistricting process for city council districts during a presentation by District 3 Councilman Zack Matheny and Geographical Information Services manager Steve Sherman to the Greensboro Neighborhood Congress.

Matheny, who is the council’s liaison for redistricting, said that the city’s two primary objectives are to ensure that the populations within the five districts are numerically balanced and to maintain two majority-minority districts. The first mandate requires that the population variance between the district with the lowest and highest population be no more than 10 percent. Greensboro’s variance is 9.2 percent, which means that the city is not required to redraw the map. And districts 1 and 2 are currently drawn so that they each have a majority African-American population, so that they are in compliance with the requirements of the federal Voting Rights Act.

A show of hands by the representatives of the neighborhood congress and other interested citizens indicated that most favor making no changes to the map, and a number of people questioned the cost to taxpayers of redistricting.

“I would like to know: Why are they wasting our time with this when there’s really no need to do it,” said Marilyn Baird, executive director of NC Occupational Safety and Health. “It’s been working fine. You know, I’m out in the community. People are talking about jobs. People are talking about housing. I want to hear about those things. This to me, you can take it back.”

At-large Councilman Robbie Perkins has previously said that he would like to redistribute at least one precinct currently represented by Matheny into another district so that more district representatives feel they have a stake in downtown development. The redistricting process led by Matheny three years ago shifted one downtown precinct each from districts 1 and 2 to District 3.

Matheny repeated a retort today that districts 1 and 2 do encompass part of downtown: District 1 includes an area to the southwest of a railroad split near the intersection of Eugene and Lee Streets. District 2 encompasses an area of South Elm Street to the south and east of the tracks that includes the Mellow Mushroom, Table 16 and Elsewhere Collaborative. District 3, in contrast includes everything on the South Elm Street corridor northward from Natty Greene’s Pub & Brewing Co., including Triad Stage, the Carolina Theatre, the Greensboro Cultural Center, the Greensboro Historical Museum, the downtown branch library, the CenterPointe high-rise, Center City Park, Lincoln Financial Group building, the VF Corp. headquarters, the Wachovia Tower, the US Trust Building and the Depot.

Today, Matheny signaled a possible willingness to give a little on downtown representation.

“I know [District 1 Councilwoman] Dianne [Bellamy-Small] is fighting hard to get more of downtown,” he said, “and if we can make that work to the betterment and without shifting a lot of precincts, I’ve got no problem with giving more of downtown to Dianne.”

Most of the sentiment at the meeting leaned towards minimizing disruptive change. Jo Isler said after the last round of redistricting she did not receive notification that she had been moved into a new district and only learned of the change when she showed up at the polls to vote during the next election.

Matheny warned that moving one precinct could set off a domino effect, requiring a complicated shuffle of precincts among the five districts.

The new Census numbers currently count 2,457 more people in District 3 than in District 1. Sherman said each precinct holds from 2,000 to 4,000 people. A newly drawn map could conceivably return Precinct G44, whose polling place is at Greensboro College and which lies to the south of Friendly Avenue, to District 1. Whether the transfer would maintain the current balance or push the city beyond the 10 percent threshold depends on how many people live in Precinct G44.

Less ambiguous is Precinct FR3, part of the Cardinal area, which was annexed into the city in 2008. The precinct is currently located in District 5, which is represented by Councilwoman Trudy Wade. Neighboring District 4 holds 4,924 fewer people than District 5, so shifting the precinct would help close the gap. The footprint of Piedmont Triad International Airport makes it appear that precinct FR4, FR5A and FR5B would be stranded were FR3 to be shifted into District 4, but Sherman said there is actually a “land bridge” that would allow to FR4, FR5A and FR5B to remain contiguous with the rest of District 5.

“Mathematically speaking, you could move one precinct and reduce the population variance,” Sherman said, adding that any political considerations are beyond his expertise.

Both District 5 and District 4 currently lean conservative, but in 2009 progressive Joel Landau came within 3.2 percentage points of defeating Mary Rakestraw in District 4. Moving Precinct FR3, which is heavily white and majority Republican, could help Rakestraw consolidate her position in this year’s election, while weakening Wade’s considerable advantage.

Matheny will host a second public input meeting on redistricting on Monday at 5:30 p.m. at the Greensboro Coliseum Special Events Center.

In other news, the Greensboro Neighborhood Congress voted to request that the city council evaluate all aspects of the impact and cost of various options for disposing of the city’s municipal solid waste and to make public all information generated by private consultants related to solid waste. The city has posted six proposals on its website from private companies for handling its solid waste, including a number that involve reopening the White Street Landfill for waste burial.

The council will receive information from consultant HDR at its meeting on Tuesday, and City Manager Rashad Young is recommending that the council schedule interviews with the private companies.

“It’s not a vote for or against the landfill; it’s what we want to do as a long-term vision for disposing of solid waste in Greensboro,” said Michael Pendergraft, who helped draft the motion.

Some at the meeting spoke out strongly against reopening the landfill.

“Ladies and gentlemen, I’m sorry, but to me it’s racial inequality,” Mary Lou Zimmerman said. “You’re dumping on people who don’t have the funds to live in $250,000 houses on the west side.”

Goldie Wells, who previously served as District 2 representative on city council, added, “The economic boom that we’ve seen with Wal-Mart and Lowes will be stifled if we reopen the landfill. And with the new Census numbers, our projected numbers show we’re going to be building thousands of new homes in the area."

The lone dissenting vote on the motion came from Kathy Hartsell, who protested that the motion’s request for an investigation of the impacts of various methods of solid waste disposal would impose an unnecessary cost burden on city taxpayers. Hartsell is a political supporter of Wade, who has expressed interest in exploring the potential cost savings of reopening the landfill.

Greensboro dollars and sense

Senior staff at the city of Greensboro learned from consultant Joe Readling last month that the city could save $1 million a year in transportation costs if it were to haul waste from its transfer station to a landfill in Randolph County instead of to the Uwharrie Regional Landfill in Montgomery County that is run by Republic Services. Randolph County is considering reopening its landfill, which went out of business in the late 1990s. The cost savings would be realized by cutting the hauling distance in half.

Meanwhile, city staff is floating the idea of privatizing the Gillespie Golf Course in southeast Greensboro, which Parks and Recreation Director Greg Jackson reports as operating at a loss. Jackson has requested permission to move forward with a request for proposals.


Politics of trash and transportation

The almost forgotten Cone-Nealtown Connector was resuscitated by Greensboro at-large Councilman Robbie Perkins in early January. A key piece of infrastructure with the potential to drive economic development in northeast Greensboro, the connector would extend Cone Boulevard out to the Eastern Urban Loop.

Perkins’ inquiry into the status of the project also creates a political trigger point for residents who live near the White Street Landfill. The connector could provide a new access point and relieve truck traffic through residential neighborhoods — a plus for neighbors — but it could also make the landfill a more viable receptacle of municipal solid waste — a definite drawback for those who call the area home.

In a Jan. 12 memo to his boss, Transportation Director Adam Fischer provides a history of how the connector slid off the city’s list of priority capital investment projects during the same period that the city council decided White Street should no longer accept municipal solid waste.

State funds obtained in 2002 allowed the city to add the connector to a list of bond projects, Fischer said. Increased construction costs in the middle part of the decade exhausted bond funds, and the project was shelved. Today, the cost of the project is estimated at $8.5 million. Fischer said the city could either issue new bonds to pay for the connector, reprioritize a slate of projects scheduled for construction in 2013, or a combination of both. Projects currently ahead of the connector include work on Merritt Drive, general sidewalk improvements and improvements to Horse Pen Creek Road.